"E. Said wrote that Israelis and Palestinians are trying to isolate themselves and to forget about each other, and I think this lucid observation shows a constant relationship between the two peoples that seems intimately related to the continued failure of efforts to find a solution to the conflict. " Introduction to the cycle of post" Notes on the political geography of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict "
|
| Map 1: Map of Israel UN |
card you see above is a correct international paper of the State of 'Israel. In it the state's borders are marked by the armistice agreements of 1949 and Jerusalem is not mentioned by the place names as its capital. The latter a rarity, seen by anyone within reach a common Zanichelli atlas or a world map hanging on the wall of their room. The paper 2 instead shows how complicated it is, after the constitution of the State of Israel and the Arab-Israeli wars, the political geography of Israel / Palestine.
|
| Map 2 |
the background of this new geographical context and in the meshes of the contrasts that characterize it, we have developed and continue to be powered, two antithetical narrative space none of which in turn is in line with the political reality of the territory (see map 1). While that part of the Palestinian community that still does not recognize the existence of the State of Israel says the area simply as if the State of Israel did not exist , the other tends to replace the Israeli intelligentsia the correct image of the state with the ideological of Greater Israel, omitting or deleting the existence of a legitimate opponent territorial space to make room for national representation in which the West Bank, Gaza and the Golan Heights are incorporated and homogenized by boundaries the State territory. For a tourist who goes to Israel is easy to find these images distorted and being a victim, ranging from common to send postcards to friends who probably stuck to the fridge magnets on our return:
|
| fig.1 A postcard from Israel |
| |
|
| fig.2 a magnet to Israel |
Moreover, these representations are scattered in various tourist guides (and usually, when present, the entire guide is to follow the spirit), then choose your guide carefully and thoroughly examined as well as the completeness of the information practice also the section on history and geography of the country.
The battle map also moves on the web pages of various sites of the official Israeli government. On the site of Ministry of Foreign Affairs (MFA) the reference to the borders of Great Israel is the norm in the representation of territory.
|
| fig.3 Caratteristiche geografiche d'Israele dal Ministero degli Esteri |
|
| Carta 3 |
Nella descrizione del moderno Israele (Modern Israel within boundaries and cease-fire lines) al 2004 (Carta 3) il sito MFA definiva i Territori della West Bank, Gaza e Golan come "sotto controllo israeliano e con status finale in sospeso". Gerusalemme non era inclusa in questa categoria e, secondo la carta, rientrava a pieno diritto nel territorio israeliano. Also in the description accompanying the paper, the calculation of the territorial extension of Israel was computed tacitly part of the occupied territories. The area of \u200b\u200bIsrael proper, ie the sum of the surface of six districts that make up the state, is approximately 20,700 sq km, the site instead reported an area of \u200b\u200b22,145 sq km .
|
| Map 4 |
In 2006, the paper of the same section of the site (Israel Within boundaries and cease-fire lines) was updated or replaced with an even more cryptic, without description, or colors that vaguely recall the demarcation of the Green Line (Map 4) .
The website of the Ministry of Foreign Affairs of Israel is just one example among many, similar to other cards available on the official websites link to Article Many official maps fail to show Israeli Occupied Territories Philip Weiss.
Geographical Narrative in Israel-Palestine is both subtle and effective weapon in the commission of mutual hatred. The minds of the people on both sides of che dall'altra vengono plasmate in modo distorto ed in questo la cartografia presente nei testi scolastici svolge un ruolo incisivo.
|
| Carta 5 Palestina senza Israele |
Un giovane palestinese che sia stato educato alla sistematica negazione dell'esistenza dello Stato d'Israele difficilmente potrà contribuire a quell' ideale processo di convergenza necessario al raggiungimento di una qualche forma di convivenza che non implichi sopraffazione; parimenti un colono o un futuro soldato israeliano svolgerà "meglio" if his work has been accustomed since childhood to think of his state in terms of geography and history of Great Israel, also will feel brave in the commission of the greatest injustice, because it will be assumed (wrongly) in the right part of who does his duty to reclaim what belongs to him. It happens that some young Israeli soldiers in the first period of their service to notice the dramatic difference between what was taught in schools and the reality with which they are called to confront once in uniform. The job of the soldier becomes so unbearable for them to force them to leave the service knowing how serious Israel, the consequences of that choice. The vast majority of young soldiers but still there on the battlefield, making each day tribute to his bad teachers.
Elements of this cycle:
Introduction to the course of post "notes on the political geography of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict "
The battle map part 1: Zionism and cartography.
The battle map Part 2: Cards as Weapons in Israel-Palestine.
A look at political lawns d ' Israel.
prospettivainternazionale
Elements of this cycle:
Introduction to the course of post "notes on the political geography of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict "
The battle map part 1: Zionism and cartography.
The battle map Part 2: Cards as Weapons in Israel-Palestine.
A look at political lawns d ' Israel.